Call now – (02) 9586 3111

Existing buildings, upgrades and Performance Solutions: questions and answers

Questions about the affected part, fit-outs and change of use, unjustifiable hardship, Performance Solutions and expert evidence. Each answer is short and links to the page that covers the subject in full. Answers refer to the code in force in NSW: NCC 2022 Amendment 2 until NSW adopts NCC 2025 on 1 May 2027.

All questions and answers

From: Renovating an apartment bathroom in NSW to age in place: approvals and design

Do I need strata approval to renovate my apartment bathroom in NSW?

Usually yes. Under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015, work involving waterproofing is excluded from minor renovations, so a bathroom renovation that disturbs or replaces the membrane is generally major work. That needs a special resolution of the owners corporation, with no more than 25 per cent of the value of votes cast against it, and the resolution must say who maintains the affected common property.

What makes an apartment bathroom suitable for ageing in place?

A step-free shower with room for a shower chair, a wider door that opens outward or slides, clear space beside the toilet, wall reinforcement for grab rails, slip-resistant floors, lever taps and good lighting. Take the dimensions from a recognised standard such as AS 4299 adaptable housing so the room works now and as needs change.

When should I involve an access consultant?

Before you lodge the strata application and before the builder prices the job. An access consultant checks the layout against the relevant accessible-housing standard and the building's constraints, such as slab setdowns, so strata, the builder and any OT recommendations all work from the same drawings.

From: Change of use and tenant fit-outs in NSW: what disability access upgrades the new work triggers

Does a tenant fit-out trigger a disability access upgrade to the building entrance in NSW?

Often, yes. New building work in an existing building must comply with the Premises Standards and the NCC access provisions. It usually also brings in the affected part: the principal pedestrian entrance and the continuous accessible path from it to the new work. There is a concession when a lessee applies for approval for their own tenancy in a building with more than one tenant. It does not apply where the building is leased to only one person.

What is the affected part under the Premises Standards?

The affected part is the principal pedestrian entrance of an existing building that contains a new part. It also covers any part of the building needed to give a continuous accessible path of travel from that entrance to the new part. In practice it can bring a stepped shopfront, an arcade entry or a lobby into a fit-out's scope, even though the tenant is not otherwise building there.

Do I need a lift to an upstairs dining area or mezzanine in a small café or shop?

For Class 5, 6, 7b or 8 buildings not more than three storeys, where each non-entrance storey is not more than 200 m², NCC D4D4(f) can remove the requirement for a ramp or lift to the upper storeys. Other access features still apply. Check the exact floor areas and classification with your certifier.

From: Expert witness disability access consultant (NSW): Makita-standard reports for NCAT and court

What is the difference between an expert witness and a compliance consultant in access work?

A compliance consultant is engaged to help a project team design, assess or upgrade a building so it better meets applicable access requirements, for example reviewing drawings, auditing an existing site, or advising on NCC and Australian Standards pathways. An expert witness is engaged when a dispute, claim or tribunal or court proceeding needs independent specialist opinion evidence. Their primary duty is to the tribunal or court, not to the party paying the fee.

When do NCAT or the courts need a Makita-standard access report?

When access compliance, design adequacy or equitable access is a live issue in proceedings, or proceedings are reasonably anticipated, decision-makers typically need opinion evidence from a witness with specialised knowledge in the accessible built environment, not a bare assertion that something is “non-compliant.” In New South Wales, Makita v Sprowles remains the practical benchmark. A routine DA or CC access report prepared only for lodgement is usually not enough on its own if the document will be relied on as expert evidence.

Can the same firm that advised on design later act as expert?

Independence and prior involvement must be disclosed and assessed. Separate appointments are often safer. Legal advisers decide. Do not assume a previous SAC compliance report can be re-badged as expert evidence.

Is a compliance access report enough for NCAT?

Usually not by itself. Expert evidence has different duties and a different structure.

No. Solicitors instruct. Experts opine within specialised knowledge.

From: What is an NCC Performance Solution? A plain-English guide for disability access in NSW

Is a disability access Performance Solution an exemption from providing access?

No. A Performance Solution is not a way out of access; it is a different way of achieving the access outcome the NCC requires. It still has to meet the relevant Performance Requirements. If a building owner argues that providing access at all would be too costly or impractical, that is a separate concept, unjustifiable hardship under the Premises Standards.

From: When your certifier asks for a disability access Performance Solution (NCC)

Can the certifier prepare the Performance Solution themselves?

The certifier determines the certificate. Preparing the solution they will certify creates a conflict risk. Engage an independent access consultant and keep the PCA in the brief loop for comment.

Do we always need a PBDB, or can we jump to a report?

The NCC process expects a brief, stakeholder agreement, analysis and a final report. Jumping straight to a conclusion is how reports get rejected.

How does this relate to our DA or CC access report?

The access report verifies DtS items and flags departures. The Performance Solution is the documented pathway for those departures.

From: Chair lifts, platform lifts and access ramps in Class 2 buildings in NSW: CDC, DA and access evidence

Can a platform lift in a Class 2 building proceed as complying development?

Only if the current Codes SEPP or another planning instrument contains a complying pathway that the proposal meets in full. Most installations in existing Class 2 common property require a development application. Confirm with the planning instrument and a certifier.

Does a chair lift satisfy wheelchair access requirements?

No. A chair lift requires the user to transfer to a seat. It does not provide independent access for a person who uses a wheelchair. An incline platform lift or vertical platform lift is the device that carries the wheelchair.

What does the certifier typically want from an access consultant?

A report that maps the device against the applicable NCC and Premises Standards provisions, identifies any Performance Solution, and confirms the interface with paths of travel and landings. The report is one input; structural, fire and lift-compliance certificates come from other practitioners.

From: Unjustifiable hardship and disability access in NSW: what it means, who decides, and what to document

Who decides unjustifiable hardship in NSW, and can my certifier approve it?

In NSW no authority grants unjustifiable hardship in advance. The Australian Human Rights Commission says only a federal court can determine it, which happens if a complaint proceeds. Your Principal Certifier assesses NCC compliance, including any Performance Solution. The certifier does not rule on a DDA defence. The practical path is to comply as far as possible, use a Performance Solution for departures, and document any remaining shortfall against the factors in section 4.1.

Is unjustifiable hardship an exemption from disability access requirements?

No. Under the Disability (Access to Premises — Buildings) Standards 2010, unjustifiable hardship is a defence, not an exemption. It is not unlawful to fail to comply only to the extent that compliance would impose unjustifiable hardship. You must still comply to the maximum extent that would not. The Standards' own example is that enlarging a lift might be unjustifiable hardship, while braille and tactile lift buttons might not be.

What evidence supports an unjustifiable hardship position?

Section 4.1(3) lists the factors, including costs and benefits, the cost relative to the building's value, the owner's financial position and any available funding, technical and topographic constraints, whether heritage features are essential or merely incidental to significance, good-faith efforts such as consulting access consultants and certifiers, any DDA action plan, and consultation with people with disability. Keep priced options, specialist reports and a record of the alternative access provided.

From: What is an NCC Performance Solution? A plain-English guide for disability access in NSW

Is a Performance Solution worth it?

Cost, time and certifier appetite versus redesign. When DTS is quicker, follow DTS. When a Performance Solution gives a better outcome for an existing or constrained building, document it properly.

What is a Performance Solution under the NCC?

A Performance Solution is a project-specific way of meeting the National Construction Code's Performance Requirements without following the prescriptive Deemed-to-Satisfy (DTS) Provisions. Under clause A2G2 it must meet every relevant Performance Requirement and be shown to do so using one or more of the NCC's Assessment Methods: evidence of suitability, a Verification Method, Expert Judgement, or comparison with the DTS Provisions. A building can comply through DTS, a Performance Solution, or a mix of both.

How is a Performance Solution prepared and approved in NSW?

The NCC sets a four-step process: prepare a performance-based design brief with the relevant stakeholders, carry out the analysis it sets out, evaluate the results against the agreed acceptance criteria, and document everything in a final report. In NSW the report is usually prepared by an independent access consultant and assessed by the project's registered certifier.

Back to all questions and answers