Call now – (02) 9586 3111

When an accessible WC pan centreline is off the AS 1428.1 dimension: Performance Solution or rectify?

In an accessible unisex sanitary compartment, the pan has to sit in a tight range from the side wall and from the rear wall. If it does not, the layout is not Deemed-to-Satisfy. That is common in public amenities, especially in existing rooms, or where the waste was set out before the pan model was chosen. A Performance Solution can be the right path, but only with measured evidence that a dignified transfer still works, argued against NCC Performance Requirements F4P1 and D1P1. It is not a way to leave a new, movable pan where it is. Sydney Access Consultants prepared a Performance Solution for an accessible WC pan centreline in a public amenities building in NSW. NSW building work is assessed under NCC 2022 Amendment 2, which calls up AS 1428.1:2021, until NCC 2025 is adopted in NSW on 1 May 2027. We author the access report and the Performance Solution; we are not the certifier and we do not supply sanitaryware.

What the Deemed-to-Satisfy set-out is

Under AS 1428.1:2021 clause 12.2.2, two pan dimensions work together as one set-out:

Those ranges are the requirement, not a construction tolerance to be stretched. A pan can be right on one dimension and wrong on the other, so a report should measure and give a status for both. The rest of the compartment (seat height, basin, door, grabrails and circulation) is covered on our disabled toilet regulations NSW page.

NSW work under NCC 2022 Amendment 2 uses the 2021 edition of the Standard. Older drawings set out to the 2009 edition use different clause numbers. Nominating the wrong edition on the drawings is a problem in itself, and it is never a reason to ignore the centreline.

Why public amenities miss it

Existing buildings

An existing toilet block or park amenity often cannot move a wall, a stack or a floor waste without disproportionate work. The pan may have been set out to an older edition, or to no standard at all. That is a typical, honest occasion for a Performance Solution, provided the transfer still works and the evidence shows it. Where retained fabric is the constraint, see heritage access Performance Solutions.

Set-out errors

The waste pipe is fixed in the slab from the wrong face (the structural wall instead of the finished lining), from the wrong wall, or before the wall build-up is known. A lining, a tiled skirting or a nib that was not on the set-out drawing will eat the range quickly. Measure to the finished side wall, and say so in the report.

Pan models

Outlet positions and pan lengths vary between manufacturers, and between wall-faced and floor-mounted models. Choosing the pan after the waste is poured is a common way to land outside the range. If a Performance Solution is justified, it covers this pan in this room. It is not a licence for the next model or the next amenities block on the site.

Why the centreline matters for transfer

A side transfer from a wheelchair depends on a consistent relationship between the pan, the side wall, the side grabrail and the circulation space beside the pan. If the pan is too close to the wall, the person's transfer position and their relationship to the rail are compromised. If it is too far from the wall, the side rail may be out of reliable reach, and the circulation on the open side of the compartment can suffer as well.

That is why the departure is assessed as a package with the grabrail provisions (clause 12.2.7) and the circulation provisions (clause 12.2.8), not as a single millimetre in isolation. The evidence is practical: a measured survey, photographs, the direction and amount of the departure, its effect on the rails and the circulation space, and an expert access assessment of whether a dignified side or front transfer is still available.

How a Performance Solution is argued under F4P1 and D1P1

A Performance Solution is another way of meeting the NCC Performance Requirements. It is not an exemption and it is not a defect waiver. Our pages on what an NCC Performance Solution is and on Performance Solutions set out the method; here is how it applies to a pan.

The Performance Requirements

F4P1, personal hygiene facilities: suitable sanitary facilities must be provided, to the degree necessary, appropriate to the use of the building, the number and gender of the occupants, and the disability or other particular needs of the occupants. A centreline departure is argued here because the real question is whether the compartment is still a usable sanitary facility for a person who needs to transfer.

D1P1, access for people with a disability: access must be provided, to the degree necessary, including to facilities for personal hygiene. The compartment has to remain one a person can approach, enter and use.

The assessment method

For a single fixture set-out, the usual methods are a comparison with the Deemed-to-Satisfy provision (what the centreline range is trying to achieve, and how the as-built layout still meets or falls short of that intent), expert judgement used carefully, and evidence of suitability such as measured drawings, the pan data sheet and photographs. The access Verification Method is built for a reference-building comparison and is rarely the right tool for one pan.

What the report must state

The Deemed-to-Satisfy provision departed from (clause 12.2.2, plus any related grabrail or circulation clause that is also off), the Performance Requirements, the assessment method, the acceptance criteria agreed in the performance-based design brief, and the limitations: this room, this pan, this measured position. Consult the certifier early. Do not ask the certifier to design the solution they will later be asked to accept.

What the certifier wants to see

A Performance Solution does not replace an incomplete measure, and it does not cure a pan that still prevents a transfer.

When to rectify instead

Put plainly: a Performance Solution is for cases where Deemed-to-Satisfy cannot reasonably be achieved and the Performance Requirements can still be shown to be met. It is not a method for leaving a new, unfixed pan in the wrong place.

An accessible adult change facility under Specification 27 is a different room with its own requirements, not a workaround for a centreline problem. See accessible adult change facilities.

Our experience

Sydney Access Consultants prepared a Performance Solution for an accessible WC pan centreline in a public amenities building in NSW. Pan set-out sits alongside the other departures that come up again and again on NSW projects; see repeated access Performance Solutions.

Answer-ready questions

What is the AS 1428.1 pan centreline, and is a pan outside that range automatically unlawful?
In an accessible unisex sanitary compartment, AS 1428.1:2021 clause 12.2.2 sets the pan centreline at 450 to 460 mm from the side wall and the front of the pan at 790 to 810 mm from the rear wall. That is the Deemed-to-Satisfy set-out under NCC 2022 Amendment 2 in NSW. A pan outside either range is not Deemed-to-Satisfy. It is not automatically a failed building if a Performance Solution shows the Performance Requirements are still met, and it is not automatically acceptable because the departure looks small. The compartment is assessed as a package with grabrails and circulation.

How is a Performance Solution argued, and what does the certifier want?
The usual Performance Requirements are F4P1 (personal hygiene facilities) and D1P1 (access for people with a disability, including to those facilities). The report identifies the departure, sets a performance-based design brief and uses a stated assessment method, typically a comparison with the Deemed-to-Satisfy intent, expert judgement and measured evidence. The certifier will want a measured set-out to the finished side wall, the pan model, the direction and amount of the departure, an analysis of transfer, grabrails and circulation, and clear limitations.

When should we move the pan instead?
If the work is still in construction and the pan or waste can still be moved, or a different pan model would land inside both ranges, rectify. A Performance Solution is for cases where Deemed-to-Satisfy cannot reasonably be achieved, typically an existing amenities room or a fixed stack, and where a dignified transfer can still be shown.

What to send, and how Sydney Access Consultants helps

Send the measured set-out or a dimensioned survey, the pan model, the room drawings, and whether the work is still in construction. Our services include DA and CC access reports (see DA vs CC access report and access reports for DA, CC and CDC), site measures, performance-based design briefs and Performance Solution reports. Call (02) 9586 3111 for a fee. The free initial consultation is a plan review only; a site measure is chargeable. Gary Finn is an Accredited Member of the Access Consultants Association, member 435.